Sunday, February 6, 2011

J.C.R. Lickider and the early days of computing

I just finished reading The Dream Machine by M. Mitchell Waldrop (not the 1991 movie...). It is a biography of J. C. R. Licklider, but it is much more than that - it is the story of the very early days of computing in the US starting in the 1950s. J. C. R. Licklider, or Lick as he apparently preferred to be called, started his career at Harvard in the Psycho-Acoustic Laboratory in 1943 after receiving his PhD at University of Rochester on that very topic. During his time at Harvard, he started attending the famous "supper seminars" organized by Norbert Weiner (who was a distinguished mathematician and is the father of the cybernetics movement). One of the problems debated at these seminars was the relationship of digital computers and the human brain. Thus started Lick's interest in computing, which shaped the rest of his life. In 1950 he moved to MIT with the promise of setting up a cognitive psychology research program and a department of psychology. He did set up a top-notch and influential program, but he could not realize the objective of setting up a department due to institutional obstruction. He moved to BBN in mid-1957 as Vice-President in charge of all psycho-acoustics research. He moved to ARPA in 1962 to head the Information Processing Techniques Office (IPTO) where he stayed until 1964. He then moved to IBM for a short while and then returned to MIT in 1968 from where he retired in 1985. He passed away in 1990.

His academic career, as it relates to computing, is very interesting and it is eye opening to read some of his papers. After I finished the book, I read his 1961 paper "Man Computer Symbiosis" and his 1968 paper co-authored with Bob Taylor (who himself became the head of IPTO later on, and is one of the fathers of the ARPANET, "The Computer as a Communication Device", both of which were included in a 1990 DEC Technical Report in memory of Lick shortly after he passed away. His vision of where computing should go, in particular his emphasis on moving from a computing paradigm based on well-defined specification (and coding) of a solution supported by batch processing to one where the system "works" with the users and "learns" along the way, and is supported by timesharing (and later interactive) computing, is very enlightening when considered in historical perspective.

Lick's ARPA days were perhaps far more influential on the growth of computing in the US. He was influential in initiating and funding projects at a few key institutions on timesharing (Project MAC at MIT, and Ed Feigenbaum at UC Berkeley), AI (again Project MAC and Marvin Minsky at MIT, Allen Newell, Herbert Simon, and Alan Perlis's work at CMU,John McCarthy's work at Stanford), human-computer interaction (Doug Engelbart's group at SRI), and he started the work on ARPAnet. He had explained his ideas of an "intergalactic computer network" in a series of memos in 1961 while he was at BBN. These ideas are also summarized in the 1968 essay "The Computer as a Communication Device". The book is very well researched and very nicely written. It is Lick's life that forms the backbone of the book, but that is not constraining at all given Lick's impact on so many areas. The projects that he funded are very well described. The projects and efforts that grew out of these early projects (such as Xerox PARC) are also included to complete the narrative.

When I completed the book, I kept thinking that new generation of students should be exposed to the history of computing in some way. There is significant value in being able to see the thread of ideas from their early germination to their later realization (sometimes decades later). I believe it would be better to weave the discussion of history into the discussion of fundamental techniques and algorithms. This requires a rethinking of how we introduce computer science -- especially in the early courses -- but that is a topic for another blog.

1 comment:

  1. Hello sir, Are you ok? You have written a unique content.
    I gonna start blogging about few days later. So, I think to read more blogs to enrich my blogging methods. I also read your posting. I like to share my Looking for Computers ny? Notebooks laptop computer or laptop computer or computer is a cellular NY laptop computer or computer that is small as much as necessary to be provided furthermore set aside on the level while doing. Find the best NY laptop computer or pcs these days.
    Thanks for this.